| Thats all. Game finished. | ||
| 90+11' | The second half ends with the match finishing 4-4 between New York City FC and FC Cincinnati. | |
| 90+11' | Foul committed by Strahinja Tanasijevic of New York City FC. | |
| 90+11' | Ayoub Jabbari of FC Cincinnati wins a free kick in the defensive half. | |
| 90+8' | Raul Gustavo from New York City FC misses a header from the center of the box after a corner. | |
| 90+7' | Corner awarded to New York City FC after Ayoub Jabbari concedes. | |
| 90+6' | Tah Brian Anunga of FC Cincinnati receives a yellow card for a foul. | |
| 90+6' | Jonathan Shore from New York City FC wins a free kick in the attacking half. | |
| 90+6' | Foul committed by Tah Brian Anunga of FC Cincinnati. | |
| 90+5' | Goal in the penalty shootout! Evander scores for FC Cincinnati with a right-footed shot into the bottom right corner. The match remains 4-4. | |
| 90+3' | FC Cincinnati is awarded a penalty after Evander is fouled in the penalty area. | |
| 90+2' | Goal! FC Cincinnati scores with Andrei Chirila's left-footed shot from outside the box into the bottom right corner, assisted by Pavel Bucha. The match score is now New York City FC 4, FC Cincinnati 3. | |
| 90+1' | The fourth official has indicated there will be 7 minutes of added time. | |
| 90' | Substitution for New York City FC: Strahinja Tanasijevic comes on for Tayvon Gray. | |
| 89' | Kenji Mboma's right-footed shot from the left side of the box is blocked. | |
| 89' | FC Cincinnati wins a corner after Thiago Martins concedes. | |
| 88' | Gerardo Valenzuela from FC Cincinnati misses a left-footed shot from outside the box, sending it to the left. | |
| 84' | Substitution for New York City FC: Jonathan Shore comes on for Agustín Ojeda. | |
| 84' | Substitution for New York City FC: Arnau Farnós comes on for Nicolás Fernández. | |
| 83' | Substitution for FC Cincinnati: Ayoub Jabbari comes on for Tom Barlow. | |
| 83' | Foul committed by Gerardo Valenzuela of FC Cincinnati. | |
| 83' | Neill from New York City FC wins a free kick in the defensive half. | |
| 82' | Keaton Parks' right-footed shot from the center of the box is saved. | |
| 79' | Goal! Talles Magno scores for New York City FC with a right-footed shot from the center of the box. The match score is now 4-2. | |
| 77' | Neill from New York City FC wins a free kick in the attacking half. | |
| 77' | Foul committed by Gerardo Valenzuela of FC Cincinnati. | |
| 77' | Kévin Denkey of FC Cincinnati is caught offside. | |
| 77' | Evander's right-footed shot from the right side of the box is blocked. Pavel Bucha provided the assist. | |
| 75' | Nicolás Fernández from New York City FC wins a free kick in the defensive half. | |
| 75' | Foul committed by Gerardo Valenzuela of FC Cincinnati. | |
| 72' | Substitution for New York City FC: Keaton Parks comes on for Hannes Wolf. | |
| 72' | Substitution for New York City FC: Talles Magno comes on for Maxi Moralez. | |
| 71' | Kyle Smith of FC Cincinnati receives a yellow card for a foul. | |
| 71' | Nicolás Fernández from New York City FC wins a free kick on the left wing. | |
| 71' | Nicolás Fernández from New York City FC wins a free kick on the left wing. | |
| 70' | Gerardo Valenzuela's right-footed shot from the right side of the box is saved. | |
| 65' | Goal! FC Cincinnati scores to make it 3-2 against New York City FC. Kévin Denkey finds the bottom right corner with a right-footed shot from the center of the box, assisted by Gerardo Valenzuela from a set piece. | |
| 64' | Foul committed by Nicolás Fernández of New York City FC. | |
| 64' | Evander from FC Cincinnati wins a free kick on the left wing. | |
| 61' | Nicolás Fernández is caught offside for New York City FC. | |
| 60' | Substitution for FC Cincinnati: Tah Brian Anunga comes on for Gilberto Flores. | |
| 60' | Substitution for FC Cincinnati: Gerardo Valenzuela comes on for Ender Echenique. | |
| 59' | VAR decision: No goal. The match remains New York City FC 3, FC Cincinnati 1. | |
| 59' | VAR decision: No goal after the match ends 3-1 in favor of New York City FC against FC Cincinnati. | |
| 57' | The goal scored by Evander for FC Cincinnati is overturned after a VAR review. | |
| 57' | Goal! FC Cincinnati scores with Evander's right-footed shot from outside the box into the bottom left corner, assisted by Tom Barlow after a fast break. The score is now New York City FC 3, FC Cincinnati 2. | |
| 55' | FC Cincinnati wins a corner after Kai Trewin concedes. | |
| 55' | FC Cincinnati wins a corner after Kai Trewin concedes. | |
| 50' | Gilberto Flores of FC Cincinnati receives a yellow card for a foul. | |
| 50' | Foul committed by Gilberto Flores of FC Cincinnati. | |
| 50' | Tayvon Gray from New York City FC wins a free kick on the right wing. | |
| 49' | Hannes Wolf's right-footed shot from the right side of the box is saved in the center of the goal by Roman Celentano. The attempt was assisted by Maxi Moralez. | |
| 47' | Attempt saved! Agustín Ojeda from New York City FC has his right-footed shot from the right side of the box saved. | |
| 45' | The second half begins with the score at New York City FC 2, FC Cincinnati 1. | |
| 45' | The second half begins with the score at New York City FC 2, FC Cincinnati 1. | |
| 45+5' | First half ends with New York City FC leading FC Cincinnati 2-1. | |
| 45+4' | FC Cincinnati wins a corner after Agustín Ojeda concedes. | |
| 45+3' | Samuel Gidi of FC Cincinnati wins a free kick in the defensive half. | |
| 45+3' | Foul committed by Nicolás Fernández of New York City FC. | |
| 45+2' | The fourth official has indicated there will be 4 minutes of added time. | |
| 45+1' | Foul committed by Kai Trewin of New York City FC. | |
| 45+1' | Tom Barlow of FC Cincinnati wins a free kick on the right wing. | |
| 45' | Hannes Wolf from New York City FC misses an attempt with a right-footed shot from the center of the box after a corner. | |
| 45' | Kai Trewin's right-footed shot from outside the box for New York City FC is blocked. The attempt was assisted by Agustín Ojeda. | |
| 44' | New York City FC is awarded a corner after Samuel Gidi concedes. | |
| 42' | New York City FC wins a corner after Samuel Gidi concedes. | |
| 41' | Maxi Moralez from New York City FC misses an attempt with a right-footed shot from outside the box. | |
| 40' | Evander from FC Cincinnati is caught offside. | |
| 40' | FC Cincinnati wins a corner after Raul Gustavo concedes. | |
| 39' | FC Cincinnati is awarded a corner after Thiago Martins concedes. | |
| 39' | Evander's header from the center of the box is blocked. The attempt was assisted by Ender Echenique. | |
| 37' | Agustín Ojeda from New York City FC misses a right-footed shot from the right side of the six-yard box, just to the right of the goal. He was assisted by Maxi Moralez. | |
| 35' | Goal! Nicolás Fernández scores for New York City FC with a right-footed shot from the right side of the box after a fast break. The score is now 2-1 in favor of New York City FC. | |
| 32' | Goal! FC Cincinnati equalizes with Kévin Denkey scoring a left-footed shot from the center of the box into the bottom right corner, assisted by Ender Echenique's cross. The match is now 1-1. | |
| 25' | Kai Trewin from New York City FC wins a free kick in the attacking half. | |
| 25' | Foul committed by Evander of FC Cincinnati. | |
| 23' | Hannes Wolf from New York City FC wins a free kick in the defensive half. | |
| 23' | Foul committed by Ender Echenique of FC Cincinnati. | |
| 23' | Substitution for FC Cincinnati: Alvas Powell comes on for Teenage Hadebe due to an injury. | |
| 22' | There is a delay in the match due to an injury to Teenage Hadebe from FC Cincinnati. | |
| 20' | Goal! Nicolás Fernández scores for New York City FC with a right-footed shot from very close range into the bottom right corner. The score is now 1-0. | |
| 17' | Foul committed by Kai Trewin of New York City FC. | |
| 17' | Evander from FC Cincinnati wins a free kick in the attacking half. | |
| 14' | Maxi Moralez of New York City FC is caught offside. | |
| 13' | Hannes Wolf's right-footed shot from the center of the box is saved by Roman Celentano in the center of the goal. The attempt was assisted by Agustín Ojeda. | |
| 10' | Maxi Moralez from New York City FC misses an attempt with a left-footed shot from the left side of the box, sending it too high. Hannes Wolf provided the assist. | |
| 9' | Toole from New York City FC takes a left-footed shot from over 35 yards, but it's saved in the center of the goal by Roman Celentano of FC Cincinnati. | |
| 8' | Nicolás Fernández's right-footed shot from the left side of the box is blocked. The attempt was assisted by Maxi Moralez. | |
| 8' | Nicolás Fernández's left-footed shot from the left side of the box is blocked. The attempt was assisted by Maxi Moralez. | |
| 3' | Foul committed by Kai Trewin of New York City FC. | |
| 3' | Evander from FC Cincinnati wins a free kick in the attacking half. | |
| 3' | Attempt missed. Pavel Bucha from FC Cincinnati takes a right-footed shot from outside the box. | |
| First Half starts. | ||